7 Best Eyeshadow For Sensitive Eyes (2021 Reviews & Guide) | Nubo Beauty (2023)

I’ve very sensitive eyes. By the minute I use my mascara and eyeliner to the minutes after I wash them off, my eyes feel irritated and dry and look pinker than normal. However, like a lot of girls, I have to put on eye makeup every day and it is sometimes a real annoyance.

In case you’ve got sensitive eyes, then you’ll need to pay close attention to the components which are in the eye makeup that you would like to use. It’s necessary that the formulations used in the cosmetics you are thinking about are mild and free from irritants. There are a number of products on the market with components that could be irritating to sensitive eyes.

Whether your eyes are brought on by allergies, contact lenses, or dryness generally, you do not need to dedicate to some makeup-free look if that is not something. The attractiveness market is chock full of cosmetics that is free of parabens, sulfates, and other components which could cause major annoyance. Here, we have constructed the 7 best eyeshadow for sensitive eyes of all sorts.

List of 7 Best Eyeshadow For Sensitive Eyes Reviews

1. Burt’s Bees 100% Natural Eye Shadow Palette

  • This eyeshadow is long-lasting and all-natural. There are three color palette choices: Countryside Lavender, Dusky Woods, and Blooming Desert. Each palette has colors that are lightly wrapped with a subtle shimmer. The colors are easy to combine and resist creasing, smudging, and fading with time.
  • But as they’re lightly pigmented, they don’t produce an extremely dark or striking appearance. You might also have to use a primer or placing powder to make certain it lasts throughout the day. Burt’s Bees eyeshadow is ophthalmologist tested and is never tested on animals.
  • Burt’s Bees eyeshadow is safe for contact lens wearers and for individuals with sensitive skin and eyes since it’s free of talc, parabens, phthalates, SLS, petrolatum, silicones or artificial perfumes. It’s created out of minerals that are safe, vitamin E, and organic extracts from bamboo and honey.

2. Bare Escentuals Gen Nude Eyeshadow Palette

7 Best Eyeshadow For Sensitive Eyes (2021 Reviews & Guide) | Nubo Beauty (2)

(Video) Neutrogena Sensitive Skin EYESHADOW + PRIMER // Wear Test & Review

  • The Gen Nude Eyeshadow Palette in Rose is a great addition to your makeup kit. Not only will it not irritate your eyes, but it is going to also provide you the rosy nude cosmetics look that you would like to attain.
  • Together with both matte and shimmers, it is possible to create several appearances! This palette includes golds and pinks which can add life to your eye makeup appearance.
  • The colors are blendable and will stay put in your eyes daily. The long-lasting eyeshadow colors are excellent for producing dramatic eyeshadow, specialist eyeshadow, and natural-looking eyeshadow looks!

3. Pacifica Beauty 10 Well Eye Shadow

  • The business specializes in organic cosmetics, therefore it shouldn’t come as a surprise that they’ve put an eyeshadow palette produced of ingredients such as coconut and mineral water.
  • The palette provides 10 beautiful matte colors of browns, pinks, and nudes that are ideal for throughout the day and also a more natural appearance.
  • It’s very important to be aware that Pacifica is a vegetarian and cruelty-free firm, meaning that its substance is very safe to use.

4. Physicians Formula Shimmer Strips Extreme Shimmer Shadow

(Video) Eyeshadow tips I wish I knew sooner for hooded eyes 👀 #hoodedeyes #eyeshadow #makeup
  • The Nude Eye palette is excellent for everyday wear and the Smokey Eye palette is very good for producing an evening appearance. But it’s essential to be aware that this shadow is much more vibrant than matte incomplete, so in the event that you would like to produce a look that’s more subtle, then this eyeshadow will not be the ideal option for you.
  • You’ll also have to use a primer or placing powder to maintain glitter particles from moving into your eyes and causing aggravation. The eyeshadow will stay put for as many as 24 hours and can be an extremely pigmented liquid powder that’s creaseless and mixes readily.
  • Physicians Formula makeup is advised by allergists, dermatologists, and ophthalmologists, meaning a good deal of thought goes into developing something that’s safe for those who have eye and skin sensitivities. All products within this brand are sterile and made with no harsh ingredients proven to cause discomfort.

5. 100% PURE Pretty Naked II Palette

  • 100% pure is a cruelty-free and vegetarian brand. They’re a really great all-natural firm! With their goods, they guarantee they don’t contain harsh chemicals, chemical preservatives, and synthetic fragrances making it very safe for sensitive skin.
  • The Fruit Pigmented Pretty Naked II Palette is a Gorgeous regular eyeshadow! These include beautiful bare and blush tones that are fantastic for any looks. These eyeshadows will provide you the organic and impartial looks which you would like.
  • This is very good for sensitive skin since there isn’t any artificial dyes palette employed within this palette – rather, it is created from vitamin-rich fruits and vegetable pigments. The vital ingredients of the eyeshadows are strawberry, strawberry, Vitamin E, Vitamin acai, and resveratrol, which can be full of antioxidants.
(Video) Makeup For Mature Skin: An In-Depth Tutorial Made Simple!

6. Honest Beauty Eyeshadow Palette

  • You may be amazed to hear that the founder of this Honest Beauty lineup is that the actress Jessica Alba. Her line of fresh beauty products includes this gorgeous palette which contains 10 shades that are extraordinarily pigmented and full of color, which makes them ideal for a night out.
  • Aside from the gentle beige along with the black that is impartial, all of the other colors of purples, pinks, browns, and golds are shimmery. The colors look great and stand out regardless of the skin tone and the item can be cruelty-free.

7. Mineral Fusion Eye Shadow Trio

  • Mineral Fusion contains nine Distinct palettes to Pick from Density, Diversity, Espresso Gold, Fragile, Jaded, Riviera, Rose Gold, Stormy, Stunning, and Sultry. The colors in each palette are richly pigmented, professionally coordinated, and also may be applied dry or wet. The darker colors can even be used to fill in your brows or even as a mild eyeliner. The colors last during the day without much evaporating or smudging.
  • This eyeshadow is fermented and never tested on animals. Mineral Fusion palettes are watertight, fragrance-free, nor use dangerous ingredients such as parabens, talcs synthetic colors, SLS, or phthalates. Mineral Fusion Eyeshadow Trio eyeshadows are made out of chamomile, meadowfoam, and vitamin E.

Ingredients to Avoid If You Have Sensitive Eyes

In case you’ve got sensitive eyes, then you’ve got to pay close attention to the components which are used in the cosmetics that you would like to use. Keep an eye out for concealed fragrances such as ethylene brassy after, denatured alcohol, and SD alcohol that could raise the odds your eyes will have a negative response. You might also have to prevent anything labeled “waterproof,” since they are frequently packed with additives which may cause eye irritations.

We have mentioned whenever some of the goods on our listing include some of those harmful ingredients, which means you don’t need to be concerned about any openings.

Aluminum Powder

The aluminum powder generates the pigments in several mainstream eyeshadows. This particular sort of powder was proven to boost toxicity levels in our bodies which could be bad for our inner organs. Start looking for titles such as pigment or aluminum metal on the ingredients label prior to purchasing.

Carbon Black

Carbon black is something that’s often utilized in eyeshadows, eyeliners, and lashes. It’s been connected with the existence of toxicity and cancer levels from the organ system. Should you see names such as acetylene black, carbon black, lampblack, sub-par, D & C Black No. 2, or furnace black, then you are going to wish to believe twice about buying this item.


Thimerosal has antiseptic and antifungal properties and is just another preservative commonly found in eyeshadow. But, thimerosal may also be toxic and result in brain damage.


Talc is used as a filler for eyeshadows. This makes sure that the eyeshadow will employ easily with a slick feel. Studies have linked talc to cancer on occasion. Even though there’s still disagreement about that, you might choose to avoid using products with this ingredient only to be safe.

Formaldehyde and Formaldehyde-Releasing Preservatives

These are generally used as preservatives and are utilized in nail, hair, and cosmetics products. Formaldehyde and formaldehyde-releasing preservatives can cause annoyance and allergies. They also have been associated with cancer. Pay careful attention to the cosmetics tag and watch out for components such as DMDM hydantoin, urea, and 1uaternium-15.

Heavy metals

Eyeshadows which are green in color or metallic in character are ones that are likely to include heavy metals such as chrome and nickel. All these are linked with respiratory difficulties and brain injury. Nickel may also result in dry or watery eyelids.


Parabens generally are regarded as bad for the skin. They’re used as additives to prolong an item’s shelf life. But it’s a toxic effect on your own body and may decrease oil production on your anus glands which contributes to dry eyes. Start looking for components such as propylparaben, butylparaben, and methylparaben on the item tag.

Cream Eyeshadow

Alternatives for cream eyeshadows are restricted for people who have sensitive eyes, but it isn’t impossible to discover. Cream-based eyeshadows remain put upon use and do not flake or fall to the corners of the eyes. Should you prefer shaving cream shadows powder, you might wish to think about buying Revlon Illuminance Creme Shadow.

Powder Eyeshadow

Powdered shadows are more inclined to enter your eyes and cause irritation. But, there are still ways to make sure your eyes remain safe if you make use of them. Utilize an eyeshadow primer that’s compatible with sensitive eyes or select a powder-based eyeshadow which could be applied dry or wet, so you can set your own eyeshadow set up. This may reduce the chance of your eyeshadow particles end up on your eyes. Products such as Burt’s Bees 100% Organic Eyeshadow and Honest Beauty Eyeshadow are all Fantastic Choices.


Eye sensitivity varies from person to person, therefore it might take you a bit of time to discover the ideal makeup products for you personally. With just a little patience and trial and error, you will have the ability to discover an eyeshadow that appears great, creates the appearance you desire, and keeps your eyes free of irritation.

It is great to know there is plenty of best eyeshadow for sensitive eyes today available on the industry. 20 decades back, the majority of these brands did not exist yet and consciousness of sensitive skin was a far cry from where it’s now. There are tons of eyeshadows for sensitive skin, but I have assembled those that I believe are the very best eyeshadows for sensitive eyes from 2020.


What eyeshadow is best for sensitive eyes? ›

Opt For Cream-Based Shadows

Powder-based eyeshadows are made up of tiny particles that can potentially make their way into the eye and scratch or irritate the surface. Using cream-based shadows instead if you have sensitive eyes lowers that risk.

Is there hypoallergenic eye shadow? ›

Kiss Freely – Hypo Allergenic Eye Shadow

This non-irritating allergy-friendly eye shadow has been specially formulated for people with allergies. Made with simple ingredients, it is free from the top 8 allergens and more. The eye shadow contains no parabens which can cause dryness around your eyes causing irritation.

What eyeshadow is best for aging eyes? ›

Finish. In general, matte eyeshadows are recognized as the best eyeshadows for older women as they are less likely to settle into creases and wrinkles and they create a smooth and even finish. They also help lift hooded eyes. Another great option for older women is satin-finish eyeshadows.

What makeup does not irritate eyes? ›

There's no specific type of make-up that irritates sensitive eyes but we'd steer clear of ingredients such as parabens, fragrance and phthalates (known as man-made chemicals to preserve products).

What is the best makeup for sensitive skin and eyes? ›

"Generally speaking, mineral-based makeup is usually better for sensitive types because the formulations don't contain harsh chemicals or irritants like dye, additives, and mineral oils," says Khan. "Which are all just fillers that can clog and aggravate pores."

How do I keep my eyeshadow from irritating my eyes? ›

Apply lubricating eye drops to each eye about 30 minutes prior to doing your makeup. Disinfect your applicators before each use to avoid contamination. Apply makeup products to the outside of your eyelashes. Avoid lining the inner rim of your lashes, as this area is very close to the tear film.

Why does eyeshadow irritate my eyelids? ›

Basically, powder eyeshadow contains talc, which is a known irritant. Powder eyeshadow can also spread and fall out around your eyes and cause an allergic reaction.

Why do my eyes itch when I wear eyeshadow? ›

It's called allergic dermatitis or contact dermatitis, and it worsens as the years go by (mainly because the skin has been “fighting” since you first began applying products of any kind to your skin).

What is the most common allergen in eye shadow? ›

According to Northwestern Medicine Dermatologist Walter J. Liszewski, MD, these common allergens exist in most types of makeup: Preservatives, like formaldehyde and sodium benzoate. Fragrances.

What color eye shadow should an older woman wear? ›

We tend to gravitate towards warmer browns, greys, and natural tones as opposed to bright blues and purples as we get older because this can make us look overdone and actually make us look older than our actual years.

Should a 60 year old woman wear eyeshadow? ›

Use cream eyeshadows

Cream eyeshadows are more moisturizing on the eyes and hide eye wrinkes better than powder ones, making them the ideal option for older skin. But that's not the only reason, cream eyeshadow also has a smoother texture, making it easier to apply to mature skin than powder ones.

What color eyeshadow makes eyes look younger? ›

Use a light pink or peach eyeshadow

Using pink or peach eye shadow is a great way to look younger when you have blue or gray eyes. Blue eyes will be enhanced with eyeshadow in a warm pink tone, while gray eyes look best with light peach eyeshadow. Pink and orange tones go perfectly with blue and gray eyes.

Is there makeup for sensitive eyes? ›

Opt for Hypoallergenic make-up

Look out for ophthalmologist-tested labels when shopping for eye make-up, as this means that a doctor who specialises in eye care has given the green light to the product in question. Avoid using fragranced eye products, too, as they can irritate and burn sensitive skin.

Which makeup brand is best for sensitive skin? ›

8 of the best makeup products for sensitive skin
  • Tula Face Filter Blurring & Moisturising Primer. ...
  • Tarte Shape Tape Concealer. ...
  • Estee Lauder Futurist Hydra Rescue Foundation. ...
  • Physicians Formula Butter Bronzer. ...
  • Maybelline New York Fit Me Matte + Poreless Powder. ...
  • Honest Beauty Extreme Length Mascara & Primer.
Feb 27, 2023

What is the best makeup for people with allergies? ›

Best hypoallergenic makeup brands
  • Clinique.
  • Marcelle.
  • bareMinerals.
  • Tarte Cosmetics.
  • Tower 28 Beauty.
  • Almay.
  • Jane Iredale.
  • Colorescience.
Jan 22, 2021

Why does eyeshadow bother my eyes? ›

In some cases, sensitivity may occur if you're allergic to the pigment that gives the eyeshadow its color. Keep in mind that it's possible to suddenly become allergic to a makeup product even if you've used it for years with no previous problems. Replace eye makeup every three months to prevent bacterial infections.

Why do my eyes tear up when I wear eyeshadow? ›

The Meibomian glands are located along the waterline and secrete oil that coats the eyeball, helping to keep tears on the surface of the eye without evaporating. If makeup runs into the eye, it can clog the glands, making eyes drier and more likely to tear up.

What am I allergic to in eyeshadow? ›

Liszewski, MD, these common allergens exist in most types of makeup:
  • Preservatives, like formaldehyde and sodium benzoate.
  • Fragrances.
  • Solvents, or chemicals used to dissolve ingredients, typically in lotions and creams.
  • Sunscreen ingredients, such as oxybenzone, which sit on top of the skin and block ultraviolet rays.

What is a common allergen in eyeshadow? ›

The main allergy culprits in makeup are parabens, imidazolidinyl urea, Quaternium-15, DMDM hydantoin, phenoxyethanol, methylchloroisothiazolinone, and formaldehyde. All of these chemicals have been linked to allergies and these allergic reactions are becoming a more common occurrence.


1. Best & Worst ~ Testing Eyelid Primers ~Urban Decay, Tarte, Milani, Too Faced!
2. MAKEUP FAVORITES for Rosacea & Sensitive Skin | Clean Beauty
(Stephanie Marie)
3. BEST Under-Eye Concealers for Mature Skin | Drugstore & Full Coverage | Dominique Sachse
(Dominique Sachse)
4. BEST Makeup of 2022 | Drugstore + Department Store | Over 50!
5. Goodbye OLD and TIRED: How to Look Younger with Cream Eyeshadow
(Maggie De)
6. Powders 101: What's the difference between loose, pressed, setting and finishing powders + TOP Faves
(Lisa J)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Saturnina Altenwerth DVM

Last Updated: 14/08/2023

Views: 6644

Rating: 4.3 / 5 (44 voted)

Reviews: 91% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Saturnina Altenwerth DVM

Birthday: 1992-08-21

Address: Apt. 237 662 Haag Mills, East Verenaport, MO 57071-5493

Phone: +331850833384

Job: District Real-Estate Architect

Hobby: Skateboarding, Taxidermy, Air sports, Painting, Knife making, Letterboxing, Inline skating

Introduction: My name is Saturnina Altenwerth DVM, I am a witty, perfect, combative, beautiful, determined, fancy, determined person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.